George

 George (Melissa*)

By Alex Gino
George


LGBTQIA+

Genre: Juvenile (Realistic) Fiction

Target Age Group: Ages 8-12, Grades 3-7

Format: Audiobook (audiobook evaluation) As a prolific listener to audiobooks, I can attest to the fact that a narrator can make or break a listening experience. It is particularly true when author, story, and narrator converge in this exemplary piece of "own voices" fiction. Jamie Clayton, the audiobook's narrator, is a transgender actress who is able to bring a sweetly nuanced character to life with genuine empathy for a shared experience (Rotten Tomatoes, 2019).

Summary: Assigned male at birth and given the name George, Melissa knows she is a girl, even if her outside doesn't match who she is inside. Melissa hopes that portraying the titular lead female role in Charlotte's Web will help her mother and her classmates see her for who she truly is. 

Justification: Librarians the world over are acquainted with Dr. Rudine Sims Bishop's  concept that literature can be a windows and mirrors that allow for different perspectives and reflective experiences for readers. All people deserve to see themselves reflected in the stories they read and young people discovering their true selves are no different. I selected George (Melissa) to satisfy the LGBTQIA+ category in my blog because of its status as a  Stonewall Book Award winner (Mike Morgan and Larry Romans Children's and Young Adult Literature Award). 

Evaluation: George/Melissa, Alex Gino's first published novel for middle grade readers is a master class in plot and posing a major dramatic question (mdq). The plot's mdq, surprisingly multi-dimensional for such a short book, focuses on the entwined storylines of will she/won't she. Will Melissa get to play Charlotte in the school's play or won't she and will she finally be able to live her truth or won't she? Gino is able to keep readers on the edge of their seat right up to the very end, but I won't tell you what happened because that would be a spoiler! 

The rainbow hued title of George/Melissa does double duty in communicating both the tone and the theme of the book. Looking beyond LGBTQIA+ connotations of the Rainbow flag, rainbows can inspire feelings of positivity. Although the subject matter of George/Melissa could be considered too heavy or intense for juvenile fiction, Gino's attitude toward the audience and the material is evident in the inspirational and amusing tone which is projected throughout the story. These feelings are reinforced in a particularly moving scene of Melissa trying on "girl clothes" for her closest ally/confidant Kelly. The author never once "talks down to the reader", but conveys an age appropriate "own voices" story.  

In spite of heavy subject matter, Gino is able to avoid the plight of didacticism and thus never talking down to their reader through their use of precise vocabulary. In addition to the use of words like "transgender" or "gay", the author consistently uses female pronouns for their transgender girl character. At first, readers may experience some confusion, but will understand as Melissa's story unfolds. 


* Author Alex Gino has stated that titling the book George was a mistake. They indicated that using George as the title instead of Melissa did not honor the true identity of the main character (Gino, 2021). 

References:
Gino, A. (2015). George. Scholastic Audio.

Gino, A. (2021). Melissa’s Story and Sharpie Activism. Alexgino.com. http://www.alexgino.com/2021/07/melissas-story-and-sharpie-activism/

Rainbow. (2021). Stonewall Book Awards List. Rainbow : A Round Table of the               AmericanLibrary Association. https://www.ala.org/rt/rrt/award/stonewall/honored

Rotten Tomatoes. (2019). Jamie Clayton. Rotten Tomatoes. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/celebrity/jamie_clayton

‌