Unspeakable: The Tulsa Race Massacre
by Carole Weatherford Brown
| Unspeakable: The Tulsa Race Massacre |
2022 Coretta Scott King Award winner (Author and Illustrator)
Genre: Non-Fiction
Target Age Group: Ages 8-12, Grades 4-6
Format: Hardcover print (Physical evaluation) Unspeakable : The Tulsa Race Massacre is a book that is best experienced in its physical format. The care extended by the creative team who crafted this book is evidenced in the sepia tinged pages. Although the same messaging would come through in an ebook presentation, the contrasts of Black and White of Tulsa, the young shoeshiner entering the elevator, and the defeated looking man with his hands raised in surrender would not feel as weighty on a single digital screen.
Summary: Tulsa, Greenwood, Black Wall Street. Most Americans have never heard of the place. In the late Spring of 1921 a young African American man stands accused of assaulting a 17 year old white female elevator operator. Racist tensions long brewing across the tracks in white Tulsa, OK boil over in what will become known as one of the worst instances of racial violence in the United States.
Justification: Carole Boston Weatherford, author of 50 plus books, has many accolades to her credit including a Newbery Honor, multiple Caldecott Honors and Awards, and multiple Coretta Scott King Awards. Floyd Cooper, a Tulsa native, has received Coretta Scott King Honors and Awards for his illustrations in previous works. Weatherford and Cooper took home 2022's Coretta Scott King Award "honoring African American authors and illustrators of outstanding books for children and young adults" (ALA, 2022). At first glance, this book could have just been selected based on the creators' combined reputations. However, this particular book stands on its on merit as evidenced by its reception and awards; it is for these reasons that this book is included.
Evaluation: As described on the book's jacket, the events of the Tulsa Race Massacre were largely suppressed. It has only been in recent years that events that occurred in the late Spring of 1921 in Tulsa, Oklahoma have been discussed openly and in the media. Carole Boston Weatherford demonstrates again her ability to craft a book for the children's market drawn from historical events that are decidedly not childish. Her use of precise language throws light on this shameful chapter of American history. Her language choices are simple, but not simplistic as demonstrated in her depiction of events on the evening of May 31, 1921, "Unchecked and, in some cases, deputized by the police, the white mob stormed into Greenwood, looting and burning homes and businesses that Blacks had saved and sacrificed to build".
The rationale behind the choice of Floyd Cooper as the recipient of the 2022 Coretta Scott King Award for illustration is clearly evident in the artistic renderings of Unspeakable: The Tulsa Race Massacre. Cooper uses sepia tinged, unsaturated colors to establish multiple moods throughout the arc of this non-fiction book. The painterly media rendered through the use of oils and erasure coupled with the almost grainy photographic quality of the illustrations transport the reader/viewer back to early 20th century Tulsa.
The mood that is established through the use of color and technique marries well with the visual element of composition. As mentioned above in the context of format, Cooper relies on double page spreads to communicate the gravitas of the subject. He conveys hope for his hometown through the composition of the last illustration in the book which depicts a circle of people of all colors, large at one edge of the page and smaller on the horizon, as they gather around a bronze monument in Tulsa's Reconciliation Park.
References:
ALA. (2022, January 24). ALA News: Carole Boston Weatherford, Floyd Cooper win 2022 Coretta Scott King Book Awards. American Library Association. https://www.ala.org/news/press-releases/2022/01/carole-boston-weatherford-floyd-cooper-win-2022-coretta-scott-king-book#:~:text=CHICAGO%20%E2%80%93%20Carole%20Boston%20Weatherford%2C%20author,for%20children%20and%20young%20adults.
Weatherford, C. B. (2021). Unspeakable : The Tulsa race massacre (F. Cooper, Illus.). Carolrhoda Books.
Young,T., Bryan, G., Jacobs, J. S., & Tunnell, M. O. (2019). Children's literature briefly (7th ed.). Pearson.